Hearing on Kavanaugh allegations puts #MeToo to the test

Brett Kavanaugh answers questions during a FOX News interview, Monday, Sept. 24, 2018, in Washington, about allegations of sexual misconduct against the Supreme Court nominee. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
A crowd gathers at Dilworth Plaza by the city hall for a walkout in solidarity with Christine Blasey Ford, who accused Brett Kavanaugh of sexual assault, in Philadelphia on Monday, Sept. 24, 2018. Survivors of sexual assault shared their stories with the crowd, and then led a march around City Hall. The walkout is part of a nationwide movement called for by Tarana Burke, the founder of the #MeToo movement. (Heather Khalifa/The Philadelphia Inquirer via AP)
President Donald Trump answers a reporters question about Supreme Court Justice nominee Brett Kavanaugh during a meeting with Colombian President Ivan Duque at the United Nations General Assembly, Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018, at U.N. Headquarters. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)
Brett Kavanaugh, with his wife Ashley Estes Kavanaugh, answers questions during a FOX News interview, Monday, Sept. 24, 2018, in Washington, about allegations of sexual misconduct against the Supreme Court nominee. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
FILE - In this Nov. 12, 2017 file photo, participants march against sexual assault and harassment at the #MeToo March in the Hollywood section of Los Angeles. No matter what ultimately happens to Brett Kavanaugh and the women who accuse the Supreme Court nominee of sexual misconduct, the Senate hearing on the allegations will offer a historic test of the #MeToo movement, which began only a year ago. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes, File)
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., flanked by Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., left, and Majority Whip John Cornyn, R-Texas, speaks with reporters about the confirmation for President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee, Brett Kavanaugh, following a closed-door GOP policy meeting, at the Capitol in Washington, Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
Brett Kavanaugh and his wife Ashley Estes Kavanaugh answer questions during a FOX News interview with Martha MacCallum, Monday, Sept. 24, 2018, in Washington, about allegations of sexual misconduct against the Supreme Court nominee. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)

WASHINGTON, D.C. — No matter what ultimately happens to Brett Kavanaugh and the women who accuse the Supreme Court nominee of sexual misconduct, the Senate hearing on the allegations will offer a historic test of the #MeToo movement, which began only a year ago.

Since it coalesced around accusations against Harvey Weinstein, the movement has toppled many prominent abusers in Hollywood, journalism and politics. But #MeToo has also been about believing survivors, and the treatment of Kavanaugh's accusers raises questions about whether that part of the mission remains largely unfulfilled.

The young movement is "fighting an uphill path, going against centuries of accepted, ingrained bad behavior," said Kristen Houser of the National Sexual Violence Resource Center. "I think people say we're at a tipping point. I don't believe that. I don't think anything's tipped."

Some advocates say the handling of the complaints — especially lawmakers' unwillingness to authorize a deeper investigation into Kavanaugh's conduct — shows how far the movement still has to go in changing the way women are treated by powerful men. Others insist that the GOP dismissal of the accusers doesn't reflect a breakdown of the movement, but the failure of a largely white, male Congress to adapt to changing times.

The tension began as soon as the allegations emerged. Republican lawmakers were initially united in their refrain: The first accuser, Christine Blasey Ford, deserved to be heard.

When a second woman came forward, instead of repeating that idea, lawmakers doubled down on their support for the judge. They hurled insults at Democrats and implied that opponents had crafted a grand scheme to torpedo the nominee.

Jess Davidson, executive director of End Rape on Campus, said the Senate Judiciary Committee's conduct has been "the most disappointing experience of my survivor advocacy so far."

Ford, a California psychologist, alleged that Kavanaugh sexually assaulted her at a party in the early 1980s, when the two were teenagers in suburban Maryland. A second woman accused Kavanaugh of another assault dating to his first year at Yale University.

Ford is scheduled to testify Thursday before the committee, which is composed mostly of men. The committee must endorse Kavanaugh's nomination before he can receive a vote by the full Senate that could confirm him to a lifetime appointment on the nation's highest court. The second accuser, Deborah Ramirez, has not been scheduled to testify.

Kavanaugh is supposed to testify after Ford. He has denied all allegations.

"I had never sexually assaulted anyone, not in high school, not ever," Kavanaugh said Monday during a televised Fox News interview.

Since coming forward, Ford has received death threats. GOP lawmakers have not accused her of lying or questioned her motives. Instead, they've suggested Ford is confused, merely misremembering the episode.

Even if Ford's account is true, others have said, Kavanaugh's nomination shouldn't be upended by what they characterize as drunken adolescent behavior.

"It was drunk teenagers playing seven minutes of heaven," tweeted Fox News columnist Stephen Miller.

Since Ramirez's account became public, GOP lawmakers and Kavanaugh supporters, including President Donald Trump, have dug in.

"The Democrats are working hard to destroy a wonderful man, and a man who has the potential to be one of our greatest Supreme Court Justices ever, with an array of False Accusations the likes of which have never been seen before!" Trump tweeted Monday.

On the Senate floor, Majority Leader Mitch McConnell called the allegations "a despicable smear" and "a new low."

Sen. Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South Carolina, said Ford should have her say, but that his mind is already made up.

"What am I supposed to do, go ahead and ruin this guy's life based on an accusation?" he said Sunday in a Fox News interview. "Unless there's something more, no, I'm not going to ruin Judge Kavanaugh's life over this."

Davidson said she's deeply disappointed by the similarities she sees between Kavanaugh's accusers and Anita Hill, who famously testified that she was sexually harassed by then-nominee Clarence Thomas in 1991.

Those hearings are now widely considered a case study in how not to treat a victim. One senator asked if Hill was a "scorned woman." Another asked, "How could you allow this kind of reprehensible conduct to go on ... without doing something about it."

Less than a year after the first story about Weinstein, "to watch lawmakers fail to do this in a different way, and to watch the public fail to hold them accountable, really makes me question how much (the #MeToo movement) has really changed hearts and minds," Davidson said.

But some advocates say GOP attitudes toward survivors don't accurately reflect the movement's gains. On the contrary: They simply make the Senate seem woefully out of touch.

GOP lawmakers are "missing the power of the last year, where people have so powerfully and importantly named their experiences," said Fatima Goss Graves, president and CEO of the National Women's Law Center.

She said Republican senators' response to the allegations — at first saying that Ford is confused or misremembering, then alleging an orchestrated smear — "dives deep into the tropes surrounding sexual violence that this whole year has been spent disrupting."

Other institutions take serious action when confronted with sexual violence, but the Senate seems to engage in "an effort to lean in to bias," she said. "This will not be a proud moment in history when people look back on 2018 and wonder how is it that the Senate was so out of touch."

Shaunna Thomas, co-founder and executive director of women's advocacy group UltraViolet, said the fact that not one but two women stepped forward is a clear indication that survivors are becoming more empowered to come out of the shadows. What's happening on Capitol Hill, she said, doesn't show the true power or impact of the movement.

"Politics always follows culture," Thomas said. Americans "shouldn't be surprised that Republican senators are not reflecting that culture change. Until they're replaced, we won't see the power of the #MeToo movement, or survivors or women in the Senate."

Complicating matters is that this discussion is taking place in a highly partisan bubble, magnified by the nation's political divide.

Sarah Beaulieu, founder of The Uncomfortable Conversation, an organization dedicated to normalizing conversations about sexual violence, said she worries about stories of sexual abuse and assault becoming "weaponized in a way that hurts both survivors and efforts around prevention, education and cultural change."

Still, she said, her conversations with people and organizations "reflect a world ready for change."


Lush reported from St. Petersburg, Florida.

People also read these

Trump ignites new firestorm: Gun backers might...

Aug 10, 2016

Donald Trump sets off a fresh political firestorm by suggesting gun rights supporters might find a...

In setback for Brazil's Rousseff, Senate puts her...

Aug 10, 2016

Brazil's Senate has voted overwhelmingly to put suspended President Dilma Rousseff on trial for...

Armstrong wins third straight Olympic women's...

Aug 10, 2016

Kristin Armstrong of the United States won her third consecutive Olympic time trial Wednesday

Complexity makes airline computer systems...

Aug 8, 2016

As airline IT get more complex and automated, breakdowns become increasingly common

Sept. 11 memorial motorcycle ride ending on a...

Aug 10, 2016

Leaders of a massive, annual motorcycle procession to the three Sept. 11 crash sites say this...

About Us

The World Insiders brings you exclusive coverage from across the globe in a timely, easy to consume format sourced directly from our regional media partners.

Contact us: sales[at]theworldinsiders.com

Subscribe Now!